McChrystal’s War

As most of you know already by now, ISAF commander Gen. Stanley McChrystal has been in the hot seat for the past 24-hours for comments that he and his aides made to a Rolling Stone journalist concerning several White House officials.  It’s an unfortunate betrayal of trust and confidence from a man whom the President has not only chosen to improve the situation in Afghanistan, but one who has been given the enablers to shape the fight there with little push-back from higher echelons.  In a way, McChrystal was to be Obama’s Petreaus.  But as McChrystal is now on his way back stateside to face President Obama, needless to say, things didn’t work out that way.

As a semi-anonymous blogger, I certainly empathize with Gen. McChrystal.  I’ve even gotten my chain-of-command spun up because of an interview I gave concerning my thoughts on the film The Hurt Locker without notifying our public affairs office as a courtesy.  I didn’t disparage the Army or its leaders, so this is easily a whole different animal, but I can still empathize.  However, I’m utterly in disbelief that someone as high profile as a four-star general with decades of experience could make such a huge mistake in a public forum like that.  To put it simply, You.do.not.criticize.your.superiors.in.public.  That respect for higher command and authority is what makes the branches of the military so effective at what they do, and today’s revelations disrupted that.

President Obama is in a difficult position here as well.  The current mission in Afghanistan is as much McChrystal’s as it is his.  McChrystal incessantly badgered the Obama Administration with requests for more troops, even making his views on the matter known to the press.  And ultimately, he won.  The American fighting force in Afghanistan is almost triple what it was before Obama became president.  Since then, McChrystal’s tactical directives and policies have made our operation in Afghanistan one of the more overtly considerate endeavors in our history.  I’m sure these facts are weighing on many at the White House and the Pentagon, especially as talk of resignation and firings have mounted in recent hours.  Whether McChrystal stays or goes, it will be hard for his reputation to rebound from this, and that’s sad.  A model officer with 34-years of service shouldn’t have to go out like this.

Disappointing.


Posted

in

by

Comments

6 responses to “McChrystal’s War”

  1. miasmo Avatar
    miasmo

    Nor should they. There is no reason to be there. Continuing the war is silly. We’re spending hundreds of billions of dollars, hundreds of lives, creating new terrorists – all for what? A few dozen Al Queda? The whole enterprise is completely bogus.

  2. JerryT Avatar
    JerryT

    Oh boy. MoveOn won’t like that.

  3. Mel Avatar

    Well, he’s out and Petraeus is in. No choice really.

  4. Jason Avatar
    Jason

    Excuses? I’d hardly call my appraisal of McChrystal particularly favorable. With that said, he had a long career that shaped many facets of current Army policy, particularly our thinking in the realm of counter-insurgency. I’m not going to disparage that.

  5. miasmo Avatar
    miasmo

    “A model officer with 34-years of service shouldn’t have to go out like this.”

    Ummm… Yes, he should.

    He was in charge of oversight at Camp Nama in Iraq when detainee abuse and torture occurred. He was instrumental in the Pat Tillman cover-up. As you yourself note, he undermined Obama’s authority by leaking his requests for more troops. There is a very good reason that our constitution mandates military obedience to our elected civilian leadership. Our democracy depends on it. I am quite dismayed to find excuses for such unacceptable behavior on a supposedly progressive blog.

  6. JMPrince Avatar

    As you said, mystifying on several levels. The author was on NPR’s ATC last night, and essentially he said he was traveling with them for a month (and not the few days planned) and evidently he claims they just ‘let down their hair’. Which again begs the question. So Very strange. I suspect he stays on, but just barely. Which is not exactly stellar either. JMP

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *