Cong. Hank Johnson’s Health Care Town Hall

icon_hank_johnson.jpgHere we are at the long awaited Town Hall Meeting! The line wrapped around the lovely campus here under a shaded walkway. Toward the back of the line (where we were until escorted to the front by a namelss friend 😉 there was little drama. A few “Fair Tax” posters and some Reform supporters hanging out in line.

Once we got closer up we heard some “If you’re against Obamacare you NEED this card”.

Congressman Johnson’s staff is well organized and I’m thrilled to report that each attendee is handed a card on which to write questions! Nicely done!

We’re getting settled in now. Will be back once things get started. If you’re reading this – we’re in the back row!


7:15 Things have gotten started. Congressman Johnson is making some introductory remarks before introducing the panel already seated on the stage. It’s a full house here and we understand that the secondary locations are also full.

Congressman Johnson is focusing on the high salaries of insurance company CEOs, high costs of health care, and his support of HR 3200. The audience is quiet and respectful. Audience claps for his criticism of “Bue Dog” Democrats and their interest in “gutting” the public option.

OK. Now all the elcted officials stand up. Phew, at least they didn’t all have to be introduced.

Citizen Cathy McClure takes the stage. Also known as The Purple Bus Lady. Son has diabetes. She is telling us the costs of his care and that an individual policy is not available. Daughter has epiliepsy. Tales of delays and expenses of health care for ill children.

First up,: Dr Sandra Ford, Dekalb County Board of Health. Mentions my favorite – our ranking National Infant Mortality rates. We should be ashamed at over 100. She’s giving us a bunch of numbers about teen smoking and sexual activity. Numbers. More and more numbers. Reminds us of the importance of preventive care and wellness. She gets a big round of applause for mentioning personal responsibility.

Next: Dr Patrice Harris, American Medical Association. AMA supports HR3200 as proposed. Emphasize doctor/patient privacy; shortage of primary care physicians; prevention and wellness; and other key issues.

Now, Dr Arthur Kellermann, Professor of Emergency Medicine, Emory University (and Grady) No “wallet biopsy” in the any emergency room. Draw the best from both public and private systems. A blended system. We’ll need courage and will. “We have to do it. Do it ths year.”

Dr Eric Norwood, President/CEO Dekalb Medical Center. Each American should be covered through a combination of public and private providers health savings accounts; Massachusetts bi-partisan approach; lower costs by covering everyone.

Mr Jeffrey Taylor CEO, Oakhurst Medical Centers. Personal responsibility, healthy living, community health.

Dr Todd Williamson, President, Georgia Medical Association. Represents 12 Medical Specialty Associations. Emphasize the importance of patient/physician relationship. He opposed HR 3200 and any public option. He’s a red-blooded Conservative. Ohhhhh! Rationing! No one should tell you that you can’t spend your own money on your medical care.

And last, Michael Young, President of Grady Health System. Believes a national system will avoid individual states setting their own programs. Support for safety net hospitals such as Grady. Increasing numbers of uninsured patients due to unemployment.

.

OK! Now for questions. JT says “This is fixin’ to turn into a circus”. Turns out the cards are only for questons for which there isn’t time to answer. We love you Hank, but you can’t respond to every “What I want to hear myself say today” comment…

Question about the Health Benefits Advisory Commission appeal process. Scott Goldstein, explains that the commission will define minimum coverage.

Oh good lord. The lines are long and the questions are not really questions.


Posted

in

by

Tags:

Comments

8 responses to “Cong. Hank Johnson’s Health Care Town Hall”

  1. J.M. Prince Avatar
    J.M. Prince

    From the last stats I’ve seen 2/3’s of all bankruptcies have as their cause (partial or major) health care bills, even for people who are well insured. So it’s a huge & vital Economic & moral issue too. Which is something we all forget at our peril.

    Thanks again for the reports from the scene. JMP

  2. griftdrift Avatar

    I was there and just wanted to give props to the organizers. Hank and Dekalb in general made us proud last night. Good event.

  3. JayT Avatar
    JayT

    I arrived early and was first in line. With me were some supporters as well non-supporters, but the conversations were civil. There were some “Fair Tax” proponents as well, spouting their usual nonsense. I don’t think they were prepared for someone to actually have a clue, so that was an interesting debate. Off topic of health care, one of the Fair Taxers was having issues with people possibly cutting in front of her. She said “I’ve been here for a long time and they are not going to get in front of me. If they get behind me that’s ok.” I asked her if she thought that was FAIR to the people in back of her and she said she didn’t care. And they wonder why we don’t trust the “Fair Tax”.

    Once inside, we were anxious but prepared for the worst. Georgia justifiably gets a large amount of bad press becausee of Congressmen like Westmoreland, Gingrey, Linder, etc., but even though there were a few hecklers, when the Congressman asked them to calm down, they did. Occasionally, members in the crowd also asked them to S-h-h-h and once again they did. This is what a town hall should be. We had a lively debate but it did not get out of control. The congressman and his staff should be commended, but, so should the people of Georgia.

  4. Susan Leslie Avatar
    Susan Leslie

    I attended the town hall meeting about the health care bill last night. I was totally embarrassed by the people who showed up who were rude and closed minded and mean.

    I was told these were Republicans, however they are not like any I have ever known. I am from an old Republican family – my great grandfather was one of the founding members of the party in fact. It was a very sad moment for me to realize the Republican party has fallen so far away from the values I remember.

    I do think the health care bill needs explaining in plain english to us and I suggest a work book or a coloring book style information book be written so that even children can understand something about it.

    I am a Democrat for sure and proud of it. It is about time someone tackled an issue as big as healthcare for Americans. We have suffered long enough – seen friend’s die as a result of insurance companies controlling their care. We know that there are elderly and handicapped out there in the nooks and crannies of our neighborhoods that barely eke by – and some perish each year usually in the winter. We know people who have lost their jobs. People who have had breakdowns and lost their marriages. And the list goes on and on. If we can make progress on something as big as healthcare for a nation we are taking steps towards eliminating addiction and malnutrition and crime and ignorance.

  5. J.M. Prince Avatar
    J.M. Prince

    Oh BTW. Those infamous ‘Medicare Death Panels’ that Ex-Gov. Sarah Palin (R, Quitter)was twittering & lying about?

    Ga. Sen. Johnny Isakson helped & fought hard to have them included in the bill. No Really. No word from Isakson’s office even trying to address the mass hysteria whipped up by his GOP colleagues. Naturally, the brave soul that he is.

    Facing South Blog has the story here:

    http://www.southernstudies.org/2009/08/death-panel-architect-a-pro-life-republican-from-georgia.html

    “Death panel” architect a pro-life Republican from Georgia?

    Last week former Republican vice presidential candidate and Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin posted a statement to her Facebook page in which she warned that President Obama’s health care reform plan would result in a so-called “death panel” with the power to kill elderly people and those with disabilities:

    Palin: The America I know and love is not one in which my parents or my baby with Down Syndrome will have to stand in front of Obama’s “death panel” so his bureaucrats can decide, based on a subjective judgment of their “level of productivity in society,” whether they are worthy of health care. Such a system is downright evil.

    U.S. Rep. Virginia Foxx (R-N.C.) also recently accused the Democrats’ health care reform plan of putting seniors “to death.”

    But there is nothing resembling the alleged “death panel” in the health care reform plan. A spokesperson for Palin told ABC News that the former governor was referring to a section promoting advance care planning that appears on page 425 of the House Democrats’ bill [pdf]. Advance care planning includes living wills and durable powers of attorney that allow individuals to make clear their wishes for end-of-life care, whatever they may be.

    And as it turns out, the cause of advance planning has been championed especially strongly by a pro-life Republican — U.S. Sen. Johnny Isakson of Georgia…”

    Yeah. Call his office and ask why he’s being such a ‘Silent Cal’, on this one of his signature issues.

    Here’s the Contact info:

    Washington: United States Senate, 120 Russell Senate Office Building, Washington, DC 20510

    Tel: (202) 224-3643 Fax: (202) 228-0724

    Atlanta: One Overton Park, 3625 Cumberland Blvd, Suite 970, Atlanta, GA 30339

    Tel: (770) 661-0999 Fax: (770) 661-0768

    JMP

  6. J.M. Prince Avatar
    J.M. Prince

    Thanks Susan, I think the priority was placed on security, so everything else was seemingly secondary. More volunteers always helps. Fewer police was probably out of the question given the level of threats & intimidation we’ve seen repeatedly at other venues around the nation.

    There were ‘overflow’ areas where you could hear the discussion though. This from a report via the DailyKos.com

    http://www.dailykos.com/storyonly/2009/8/10/764812/-Hank-Johnson-Townhall,-GA-4.-We-came-out-in-force!

    Thanks for your participation & note. JMP

  7. Susan Oakes Avatar
    Susan Oakes

    My husband and I showed up at the August 10, 2009 Town Hall meeting at Perimeter College prior to 6 PM. The lines were already beyond long, and grew even longer once we secured our polite place in the line. After an 1.5 hour wait, we were turned away as the gym was completely filled. The lines snaked around and were poorly drawn, and the folks at the end of the line managed to move ahead and secure a better position than the courteous folks who arrived earlier. The public would have been better served if there had been less police protection and more volunteers/ coordinators to manage the people flow/paths. Perhaps any future town hall meeting coordinators should anticipate a large turnout and plan accordingly. That would ease the disappointment to those that are unable to be accommodated.

  8. J.M. Prince Avatar
    J.M. Prince

    Thanks for the report Bernita. It’s always good to hear from one of the few Reps in Ga. who openly embraces the concept of reform. And of course no where in the world is this true:

    “No one should tell you that you can’t spend your own money on your medical care”.

    Anywhere. Even in China, the UK, Canada, France, or Russia. Another red herring.

    Thanks for being there. JMP

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *